Only Original quality backs up your photos and videos in Google Photos at their full original resolution. Storage saver (once called High quality) uploads a compressed copy, which How-To Geek reports means photos are downsized to 16 MP and 4K video to 1080p. Express is another reduced option.
So seeing "Backed up" in the app doesn't tell you much. It tells you a copy exists, not whether that copy is the file your camera made.
Why does the difference matter for a normal photo?
Picture a family photo you want printed big for a party banner. If your phone's camera shoots above 16 MP and you back up with Storage saver, the cloud copy has fewer pixels than the original. That's fine for a phone screen. For the banner, it may not be.
iTechGuides says Google recommends Original quality for photos above 16 MP, videos above 1080p, and large banner prints. The same article says Storage saver photos print well up to 24×16 inches at 16 MP. For most snapshots, you won't see the difference. For the shots you may print large or edit heavily, you might.
One point in Storage saver's favour: iTechGuides also says the setting changes the uploaded copy, not the file on your phone. As long as the original is still on the device, nothing is lost yet. The risk comes when you delete it from the phone to free space and the cloud copy is all that's left.
What is Express quality?
Express is a third backup option that appears on Google's backup quality help page alongside Storage saver and Original quality.
The page sets out the choices differently for different devices, and some sections list only Storage saver and Original quality. If you don't see Express in your app, check that help page for your device.
How do you see which backup quality you're using?
On older versions of the app it's labelled Backup quality. Menu names change between app versions, so if yours looks different, look for either of those labels inside the Backup settings.
Check every device that backs up to your account. Google's help page says changing the backup quality on one device doesn't change it on your other devices. Your phone could be on Original quality while an old tablet quietly uploads in Storage saver.
Does Storage saver count toward your Google storage?
Yes, for anything uploaded recently. Google's help page says Original quality counts toward your Google Account storage. iTechGuides says Storage saver and Express uploads made on or after 1 June 2021 also count toward storage, while older eligible uploads don't.
So Storage saver doesn't make backups free. It makes each item smaller, so the same storage holds more of them. That trade can be worth making if you're near your limit, but you're paying in detail rather than avoiding the bill.
The Pixel exception
Some Pixel phones get different rules, and they vary by model. Google's help page mentions items backed up in Original quality on or before 31 Jan 2022 staying free for one Pixel context, a 16 Jan 2021 cutoff for another, and one Pixel context with unlimited Original quality and no Storage saver option at all. If you own a Pixel, read the section of Google's page for your exact model rather than relying on a general answer.
Can you convert existing photos to Storage saver?
Not by changing the backup setting. iTechGuides says the setting only affects future uploads, and existing items are handled by a separate "Recover storage" or web conversion tool. The same source says you can't change the setting at all if your account is already out of storage, so act before you hit the limit.
Some items can't be shrunk. Google's help page says these show "Not eligible for Storage saver".
Going the other way is different. Switching from Storage saver to Original quality doesn't restore detail to photos that were already compressed. The original only exists if it's still on your phone or somewhere else. The Express exception on Google's page, where switching re-uploads existing items, applies to Express specifically.
What to do now
Open Google Photos on each device that backs up to your account and check the Upload size or Backup quality setting. Put any device that holds photos you care about on Original quality, and leave Storage saver for devices where you mainly need a viewable copy. Before you delete originals from a phone to free space, confirm they were uploaded in Original quality, because a Storage saver copy is all you'll have left. If you're auditing phone backups generally, note that chat apps have their own systems, such as WhatsApp's separate cloud backup.